
5JT have been private detectives this week, considering the evidence in the case of Salim’s disappearance in The London Eye Mystery… We wrote balanced arguments to weigh up the reasons why one of the characters may or may not have been lying about what happened, and then gave our own verdicts.
The whole class did brilliantly, but there are a few examples that I wanted to share – Felix, Ethan and Ryan all did really well at using the features of a balanced argument to consider the evidence available. Well done!
Here’s Felix’s argument:
Firstly the man could be lying because he said he gets vertigo but he is here where there are lots of tall hills and ramps. I feel that he told Kat about the scooters to distract us.Also he didn’t talk about Salim like we asked. As well as this, he is claustrophobic why would he by a ticket for the london eye?
But as well as that he could have been given the ticket and could have thought he could do it. plus, he could have told Kat of the scooters because he’s nice and he could have gone because its his job. Also theres a small possibility he’s a secret agent and that could be his cover story.
All in all i think the security guard is not guilty because well you cant arrest a man for doing his job and being nice even if he is a bit scared of heights.
Here’s Ethan:
This guy is lying…
He’s a security man, so why would they get him if he’s scared of heights? Secondly , why would he wanted to distracted Kat and ted ? maybe he wanted to change the subject so that they could not find out what happened to Salim. In my opinion , the man maybe got the ticket so Salim could get lost , he must of lied about being claustrophobic . Finley, why would he be so nice.
But he could be telling the truth …
Maybe when he got his story wrong it could just be that he gets his words wrong. As well as that when he wore that t-shirt, its not good but it’s not a crime , is it ? Or he might of distracted Kat and ted so he could get on with his work instead of sitting there all day. And when he let Kat, Ted and Salim have the ticket, he was just doing something nice.
Well I think that he’s lying and that he should be arrested –ARRESTED !!!
But I must find more evedents.
And here’s Ryan:
I think he is lying because he quickly changed the subject therefore he did not want Kat and Ted to find out what happened. Secondly, he wearing his work clothes even though he was just wearing his work t-shirt. . I am sure he is lying as he was eager to get rid of Kat and Ted .
On the other hand he is not lying, it is pretty easy to forget stuff. Also wearing your uniform is not a crime then he could be a good guy. Any way a security man would not lie or would he? Why should we believe kids they always tell lies…
To sum it up I want to say he is lying a security guard scared of heights! Also him changing the subject every 5 minutes. In my opinon also saying kids lie is even worst. I think he is evil…
Good work guys!
What do you think? Let us know what you like about these pieces of writing, and what you think could be improved…
Report Post As Inappropriate